Last Updated September 12, 2023

4 incredible wedding cake bakers in Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Based on 260 reviews, we’ve analyzed and categorized the best wedding Cake Bakers in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Read on to see which ones our expert editors chose as their favorites! Our Process

Written by Steven Inge, a Virginia based wedding photographer with 10 years of experience in the wedding industry.

Home>Cake Bakers>Lancaster, Pennsylvania Wedding Cake Bakers

Roll out the red carpet and prepare to be dazzled by our star-studded lineup of Lancaster, Pennsylvania's finest wedding cake bakers (and don't forget the importance of capturing these sweet memories with a Lancaster wedding photographer)! Much like the classic movie quote, "You had me at hello," these top-notch bakeries will have you at first bite. Inspired by the sweet words of Elizabeth Barrett Browning's poem, "How do I love thee? Let me count the ways," we've carefully curated a list of Lancaster's premier pastry artists to help you celebrate your love story in the most delicious way possible. As the famous love song "At Last" by Etta James goes, "my love has come along" - and so has the perfect selection of wedding cake bakers for your big day in the beautiful city of Lancaster. Get ready to indulge in the ultimate dessert experience that will leave your taste buds singing with joy!

The Best Wedding Cake Bakers in Lancaster, Pennsylvania at a glance

About These Wedding Cake Bakers

Lancaster, Pennsylvania is home to some truly show-stopping wedding cake bakers, known for their unique creations and dedication to quality ingredients. These talented bakers have gained recognition from popular TV shows and prestigious magazines, showcasing their ability to turn any wedding dessert into a work of art. With a focus on personal style and a passion for their craft, these Lancaster-based bakeries are ready to make your wedding day even sweeter with their dazzling, mouthwatering masterpieces!

Logo

Lancaster Cupcake LLC

Lancaster, Pennsylvania Wedding Cake Bakers

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf Star

4.9 (76)

Starting Price Per Slice: $5

Review Analysis From Our Editor

Most delicious in Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Lancaster Cupcake is a wedding bakery vendor that has received rave reviews from their customers. One unique characteristic of Lancaster Cupcake is their wide variety of flavors, including gluten-free and vegan options. As one reviewer mentioned, "They have unique flavors and even include gluten-free/vegan cupcakes. You can't even tell which cupcakes are gluten-free/vegan- they're all so yummy!" Another standout feature of Lancaster Cupcake is their exceptional customer service. Customers praised the wedding coordinator, Alexa, for being easy to work with and responsive to any questions or changes. Additionally, Lancaster Cupcake offers rental display options and provides delivery and set up services, making the whole process seamless for couples. Overall, customers were impressed with the delicious taste, beautiful presentation, and accommodating nature of Lancaster Cupcake. As one reviewer exclaimed, "Lancaster Cupcake was so easy to work with, the hardest part was choosing the flavors. They will forever be our go-to bakery for all our future celebrations."

Lancaster Cupcake is a wedding bakery vendor that has received rave reviews from their customers. One unique characteristic of Lancaster Cupcake is their wide variety of flavors, including gluten-free and vegan options. As one reviewer mentioned, "They have unique flavors and even include gluten-free/vegan cupcakes. You can't even tell which cupcakes are gluten-free/vegan- they're all so yummy!" Another standout feature of Lancaster Cupcake is their exceptional customer service. Customers praised the wedding coordinator, Alexa, for being easy to work with and responsive to any questions or cha...Read More

Review Stats
Helpful96/100
Delicious94/100
Flexible90/100
Verified Review Quotes

"Lancaster Cupcake is SO DELICIOUS! When we were wedding planning we tried so many desserts around Lancaster, but nothing comes close to Lancaster Cupcake! They have unique flavors and even include gluten free/ vegan cupcakes. You can't even tell which cupcakes are gluten free/ vegan- they're all so yummy! We opted for the mini cupcakes and they were devoured quickly! Everyone raved about how delicious they were."

Reviewed on: 6/5/2023

About Lancaster Cupcake LLC

Lancaster Cupcake is not just your ordinary bakery, having gained fame on the popular show "Cupcake Wars" and ranking among the 101 Best Cupcakes in America! This Pennsylvania favorite takes pride in being a PA Preferred business, using only top-notch ingredients harvested from Lancaster County itself. With a dedication to personal style, Lancaster Cupcake crafts each cupcake to be a unique, dazzling delight tailored to the desires of any loving couple. So why not let your imagination run wild and turn an ordinary wedding into an extraordinary memory, all with the help of Lancaster Cupcake?

Lancaster Cupcake is not just your ordinary bakery, having gained fame on the popular show "Cupcake Wars" and ranking among the 101 Best Cupcakes in America! This Pennsylvania favorite takes pride in being a PA Preferred business, using only top-notch ingredients harvested from Lancaster County itself. With a dedication to personal style, Lancaster Cupcake crafts each cupcake to be a unique, dazzling delight tailored to the desires of any loving couple. So why not let your imagination run wild and turn an ordinary wedding into an extraordinary memory, all with the help of Lancaster Cupcake?

Contacts

INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/lancastercupcake/

ADDRESS: 260 Granite Run Dr. Lancaster, PA, 17601

PHONE NUMBER: 717-668-4808

Logo

Flouretta Sweet

Lancaster, Pennsylvania Wedding Cake Bakers

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarFull Star

5.0 (48)

Starting Price Per Slice: $7.50

Review Analysis From Our Editor

Most creative in Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Blayre, the wedding Bakery vendor, has received rave reviews for her talent, professionalism, and love for what she does. One unique characteristic that stands out is her openness and support for working with LGBTQ+ couples. As one review states, "Finding someone who is so open and supportive in working with LGBTQ+ couples was very important to us. Not only is that one of Blayre’s main talents, she also gave us incredible recommendations for our other vendors that made our day above and beyond anything we could have imagined." Blayre's attention to detail is also unmatched, as she ensures that every aspect of the desserts is perfect, even down to setting aside desserts in case the couple is too busy to enjoy them on the day of the wedding. Her creativity shines through in her designs and cake flavors, making her cakes truly one of a kind. Overall, Blayre is described as an incredible baker, artist, and person, and working with her is a joy.

Blayre, the wedding Bakery vendor, has received rave reviews for her talent, professionalism, and love for what she does. One unique characteristic that stands out is her openness and support for working with LGBTQ+ couples. As one review states, "Finding someone who is so open and supportive in working with LGBTQ+ couples was very important to us. Not only is that one of Blayre’s main talents, she also gave us incredible recommendations for our other vendors that made our day above and beyond anything we could have imagined." Blayre's attention to detail is also unmatched, as she ensures that...Read More

Review Stats
Delicious96/100
Artistic96/100
Creative94/100
Verified Review Quotes

"Blayre is truly a master at her craft and will make you a one of a kind cake that will blow your mind! She has such a unique eye and artistic vision and every cake she makes is stunning."

Reviewed on: 8/29/2022

About Flouretta Sweet

Flouretta Sweet, nestled in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, is dedicated to making sweet dreams come true on any couple's big day! With a Baking & Pastry Arts Management degree from The Culinary Institute of America under her belt, the owner, Blayre, crafts masterpieces that cater to various dietary needs, such as gluten-free, lactose-free, nut-free, and even vegan options. The week-of wedding schedule promises a fresh, scrumptious cake, while giving the option to complement it with cookies, cupcakes, and pastries. To top it all off, Flouretta Sweet offers display rentals, cake cutters, and cake stands for the ultimate dessert presentation. Make your wedding day extra memorable with a delectable, show-stopping cake courtesy of Flouretta Sweet!

Flouretta Sweet, nestled in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, is dedicated to making sweet dreams come true on any couple's big day! With a Baking & Pastry Arts Management degree from The Culinary Institute of America under her belt, the owner, Blayre, crafts masterpieces that cater to various dietary needs, such as gluten-free, lactose-free, nut-free, and even vegan options. The week-of wedding schedule promises a fresh, scrumptious cake, while giving the option to complement it with cookies, cupcakes, and pastries. To top it all off, Flouretta Sweet offers display rentals, cake cutters, and cake stan...Read More

Contacts

WEBSITE: https://flourettasweet.com/

INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/flourettasweet/

ADDRESS: Lancaster, PA, 17545

Logo

Salt And Light Pastry Co

Lancaster, Pennsylvania Wedding Cake Bakers

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarFull Star

5.0 (6)

Price Per Serving: Starts at $7 per person.

Review Analysis From Our Editor

Most beautiful in Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Salt and Light Pastry Co. is a wedding bakery vendor that is highly praised for their unique and delicious creations. One reviewer mentioned that they had a wonderful experience with Ruby, the owner of the bakery. Ruby was able to take their loose ideas and turn them into a beautiful carrot cake with horchata mousse and cream cheese frosting, which honored their Mexican heritage. The cake not only looked stunning with its semi-naked design, but it also tasted delicious. Another reviewer mentioned that Salt and Light Pastry Co. offers the most unique and delicious flavors with gorgeous presentation. They daydream about these cakes and even their husband, who is not a dessert person, became obsessed. The bakery also impressed another customer with their Christmas Bake Boxes and macarons, which arrived promptly and were both beautiful and delicious. The presentation of the tasting boxes for the wedding cake was excellent, and the samples were large and tasty. Overall, Salt and Light Pastry Co. is known for creating the most delicious and beautiful baked goods, including chocolate chip cookies, macarons, and watercolor cookies. They are praised for their unique and seasonal treats, such as macaroons and stuffed meringues. One reviewer mentioned that they didn't know cookies could be so gorgeous until they tried Salt & Light's creations. With their thoughtful and creative approach to baking, Salt and Light Pastry Co. is a fantastic choice for anyone looking for a sweet treat or a memorable wedding favor.

Salt and Light Pastry Co. is a wedding bakery vendor that is highly praised for their unique and delicious creations. One reviewer mentioned that they had a wonderful experience with Ruby, the owner of the bakery. Ruby was able to take their loose ideas and turn them into a beautiful carrot cake with horchata mousse and cream cheese frosting, which honored their Mexican heritage. The cake not only looked stunning with its semi-naked design, but it also tasted delicious. Another reviewer mentioned that Salt and Light Pastry Co. offers the most unique and delicious flavors with gorgeous presenta...Read More

Review Stats
Creative98/100
Unique94/100
Delicious90/100
Verified Review Quotes

"The most unique and delicious flavors with the most gorgeous presentation!! Seriously I daydream about these cakes."

Reviewed on: 6/9/2022

About Salt And Light Pastry Co

Dessert lovers, rejoice! Salt and Light Pastry Co. dazzles with eye-catching and mouthwatering dessert masterpieces, thanks to Chef Ruby's commitment to merging the flavors and intricacies of restaurant pastry with the bakery industry. Each scrumptious creation boasts unique natural flavors, fresh flowers, and joyful decorations, ideal for any event from corporate gatherings to intimate celebrations. Nestled in Lancaster City, Pennsylvania, the bakery's remarkable wedding creations showcase the finest regional ingredients and have earned accolades from sources such as Louisiana Cookin' Magazine and the Food Network's Spring Baking Championship. Get ready to let Ruby and her team bring your dream dessert to life, leaving guests craving more!

Dessert lovers, rejoice! Salt and Light Pastry Co. dazzles with eye-catching and mouthwatering dessert masterpieces, thanks to Chef Ruby's commitment to merging the flavors and intricacies of restaurant pastry with the bakery industry. Each scrumptious creation boasts unique natural flavors, fresh flowers, and joyful decorations, ideal for any event from corporate gatherings to intimate celebrations. Nestled in Lancaster City, Pennsylvania, the bakery's remarkable wedding creations showcase the finest regional ingredients and have earned accolades from sources such as Louisiana Cookin' Magazin...Read More

Logo

Dolly's Delights

Lancaster, Pennsylvania Wedding Cake Bakers

About Dolly's Delights

The delicious journey of Dolly's Delights started with a single birthday cake in 2015 that took everyone's breath away, thanks to the amazing talents of Tera O'Bryant. Fast forward to today, and this Berks County-based bakery has flourished, captivating taste buds in Philadelphia, Chester County, and Lehigh County too. What makes them extra special is Tera's genuine devotion to her craft, leading her to offer baking classes for fellow enthusiasts and creating unforgettable wedding treats that bring joy to every celebration. With Dolly's Delights, your wedding cake experience is bound to be nothing short of fabulous!

The delicious journey of Dolly's Delights started with a single birthday cake in 2015 that took everyone's breath away, thanks to the amazing talents of Tera O'Bryant. Fast forward to today, and this Berks County-based bakery has flourished, captivating taste buds in Philadelphia, Chester County, and Lehigh County too. What makes them extra special is Tera's genuine devotion to her craft, leading her to offer baking classes for fellow enthusiasts and creating unforgettable wedding treats that bring joy to every celebration. With Dolly's Delights, your wedding cake experience is bound to be not...Read More

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I consider when choosing a wedding bakery vendor in Lancaster, Pennsylvania?
When choosing a wedding bakery vendor in Lancaster, PA, consider factors such as their experience, portfolio, customization options, and customer reviews. Additionally, inquire about their availability, pricing, and ability to accommodate any dietary restrictions. It's also important to schedule a cake tasting to ensure the flavors and textures align with your preferences.
How much does a wedding cake from a Lancaster, PA cake baker typically cost?
The cost of a wedding cake in Lancaster, PA can vary greatly depending on the size, design, and flavors chosen. On average, couples can expect to spend between $400 and $800 for a wedding cake from a reputable cake baker in the area. However, more elaborate designs or specialty flavors may increase the cost.
Can Lancaster, PA wedding cake bakers accommodate dietary restrictions and allergies?
Most wedding cake bakers in Lancaster, PA are able to accommodate dietary restrictions and allergies, such as gluten-free, dairy-free, or nut-free options. It's important to discuss your specific needs with the cake baker during your consultation to ensure they can create a cake that meets your requirements.
How far in advance should I book a wedding cake baker in Lancaster, PA?
It's recommended to book your wedding cake baker in Lancaster, PA at least six months in advance of your wedding date. This allows ample time for consultations, tastings, and design planning. However, some popular bakeries may book up even earlier, so it's best to start your search as soon as possible.
Do Lancaster, PA wedding cake bakers offer cake tastings?
Most wedding cake bakers in Lancaster, PA offer cake tastings as part of their services. This allows couples to sample different cake flavors and fillings before making a final decision. Some bakeries may charge a small fee for tastings, while others include it as part of their overall package. Be sure to ask about tastings during your initial consultation with the cake baker.